Top 10 Rare Blue Pennies That Could Be Worth $78 Million

The coins in my pocket rarely command attention anymore. Like most Americans, I’ve developed the habit of tossing spare change into jars, cup holders, or between couch cushions without a second glance. But after a chance encounter with veteran coin collector Martin Weiss at a local flea market, I’ve never looked at pennies the same way again, particularly those with unusual blue coloration.

“Most individuals have no idea they might be using retirement money,” Weiss told me as he glanced at a tray of what seemed like ordinary cents. He grasped a 1943 steel penny that had a pale blue hue to it. “This little gem? Worth about seventy-five dollars in this state.”

My journey into the fascinating world of blue-colored pennies revealed surprising stories of wartime necessity, chemical changes, and minting errors that have yielded some of numismatics’ most prized treasures.

Following are the top 10 blue pennies that could be hiding in your loose change, piggy bank, or grandfather’s old collection.

1. The 1943 Steel Cent: America’s Original Blue Penny

Value Range: $5–$1,000+

Arguably the most famous “blue penny” is not technically an error. Copper was in short supply for war-related purposes during World War II, so the U.S. Mint made 1943 pennies out of zinc-coated steel instead. The distinctive coins, often called “steelies,” are silvery in appearance when new but develop a distinctive blue color with age.

“The steel cent was a patriotic sacrifice,” said numismatist Claire Rodriguez, whose collection includes several mint-condition examples. “Every penny saved enough copper to make bullet casings for the soldiers. That history makes them special aside from their unusual appearance.”

While circulated specimens remain fairly abundant and cheap ($5-15), uncirculated specimens with full original luster are valued at $50-100. Error varieties, like the famous off-center strikes, can fetch several hundred dollars.

What makes these truly valuable is their condition. James Rothstein, who’s been dealing coins in Chicago for three decades, showed me one encapsulated in a grading service holder. “This one’s MS-67—nearly perfect. The last one like it sold for $950 at auction. Not bad for a penny, right?”

2. The 1943 Copper Penny: The Blue Penny’s Coveted Cousin

Value Range: $100,000–$1,500,000

While not blue in color, the 1943 copper penny is the reverse of the steel cent story. When the Mint switched to steel, a few copper planchets (striking blanks in waiting) reportedly were left in the presses and created what are arguably the most recognized error coins in American numismatic history.

Picture them as the Blue Steel Brothers,” historian Meredith Chang said. “They are very scarce—only about 20 authenticated specimens have been observed at the three mints in total.”

Their scarcity has spawned astronomically high prices, with one specimen selling in 2010 for $1.7 million. Unfortunately, that price has also spawned millions of imitations, typically by copper-plating genuine steel cents or falsifying dates on 1945-48 copper cents.

The fastest test is a magnet,” Rothstein cautioned. “A genuine copper 1943 won’t adhere. But authenticating by an expert is a must before jumping for joy.”

3. Toned Lincoln Memorial Cents: Nature’s Blue Artwork

Value Range: $5–$500

Not all worthwhile blue pennies resulted from production changes or errors. Some of the most beautiful and most valuable blue cents are the result of natural toning processes. When copper interacts with sulfur compounds over a period of time, the resulting patina that forms can produce beautiful blue, purple, and rainbow colors.

“It’s essentially controlled corrosion,” said metallurgist Sandra Parks. “The same reaction that turns copper roofs green can create lovely coloration on cents if the atmosphere is just right.” While artificially toned coins exist, naturally toned issues, particularly those having vivid blues ringing around the Lincoln Memorial on the reverse, have an avid following.

Coins with uniformly toned, attractive patterns can sell for 10-50 times their face value to collectors of toned coins. The most sought-after coins are cents that were stored for decades in their own mint bags or Whitman albums, in which gentle chemical interactions created stable, attractive patterns. “They’re all one of a kind, like fingerprints,” Parks explained. “That’s what makes them so compulsive to collect.”

4. The 1949 “Blue Sac” Penny Error

Value Range: $1,000–$7,500

One of the rarest blue pennies is a sensational San Francisco Mint error coin. While producing 1949-S cents, something unusual happened: a limited number of coins were randomly treated with a bluish coating unlike anything that was happening before or since.

“The working theory is contaminated planchets,” explained error coin expert Thomas Greene. “Something during the preparation of the metal added elements that provided the coins this distinctive blue-gray color.”

Numismatist researcher Jessica Warren suggests another theory: “Documentation suggests that an experimental anticorrosive treatment might have been tested on a small production. Whatever the reason, these coins instantly differentiate themselves from normal ’49 pennies”.

Authenticated examples in higher grades, with fewer than 200 specimens believed to exist, have seen their prices soar over the past decade. A particularly well-preserved, colorful one sold for $7,200 at a 2023 Heritage auction.

5. Blue-Spot Lincoln Cents: Chemical Curiosities

Value Range: $5–$200

Oftentimes, the most interesting numismatic finds come from simple accidents. Lincoln cents with very apparent blue spots or patches are often the result of the coin’s interaction with chemicals or contaminants in its environment.

“I’ve seen spectacular examples that sat near cleaning products in cash registers,” said collector Marcus Johnson, who specializes in error and variety coins. “The copper and zinc in modern pennies react dramatically with certain chemicals, creating electric blue spots that can’t be replicated.”

While most spotting cheapens a coin, more specifically colored or unusual patterns have gained their own collector market. Johnson showed me a 1987 cent with a near-perfect blue circle in Lincoln’s portrait. “Paid $85 for this one. It doesn’t have any value in the traditional sense, but to variety collectors, these oddities are special.”

6. The 1969-S Doubled Die Cent with Blue Toning

Value Range: $25,000–$150,000

The 1969-S Doubled The Obverse cent is already rare to the point that less than 100 verified pieces exist. But examples of natural blue toning are the holy grail among many collectors. “It’s the storm of a lifetime,” said auction expert Eleanor Martinez.

“You have rarity with the doubling error and then aesthetic value with toning. When those two come together, prices go into a whole different stratosphere.” Doubling is most easily seen in the date and the words “LIBERTY” and “IN GOD WE TRUST.”

When paired with lovely blue toning, these already-rare coins can command high premiums over their toneless equivalents. A blue-toned specimen that had been graded MS-64 by PCGS in 2022 sold for $126,500 around 40% more than similar graded, tone-less specimens had previously been selling for.

7. Blue-Tint Steel Cents from Canada (1943-1944)

Value Range: $10–$500

America had company in making steel cents roll during World War II. Our neighbor to the north, Canada, rolled steel pennies in 1943 and 1944, and they have a tendency to get an even bluer hue than their American equivalent.

“Canadian coinage was plated differently,” said international coin expert David Yeung. “Their aromas tend to go to a richer, more uniform blue coloration that some collectors prefer to the American ones.”

While cheaper to produce than American steel cents on an average basis, mint with heavy blue coloring has been even more in demand among American collectors to have complete steel cent collections along with their international counterpart versions.

“I make people buy up whole collections of rainbow-colored collections with variably colored steel cents of each country,” Elizabeth Chen explained, being a dealer. “Canadians’ blues typically feature most often within the sets.”

8. Chemically-Induced Blue Errors: Laboratory Curiosities

Value Range: $20–$1,000

Some of the bluest pennies resulted from unexpected chemical exposure while being minted. There are reports that in several instances, planchets have come into contact with cleaning agents or other chemicals at the mint, and this has produced typical blue colors that changed limited amounts of coins.

“These aren’t really die or striking process mistakes,” said error coin expert Jason Williams. “But they are intriguing manufacturing incidents that resulted in one-time effects.”

Such incidents are documented to have occurred in 1958, 1964, and 1972, but the exact numbers involved are unknown. The most famous occurred at the Denver Mint in 1972, when a quantity of thousands of cents were immersed in a cleaning agent that created an electric-blue glow.

“The ’72-D chemical blues are immediately recognizable,” said Williams. “They have an almost neon quality that no natural toning could produce.”

9. Blue-Toned Indian Head Cents (1859-1909)

Value Range: $50–$5,000+

While we’ve focused primarily on Lincoln cents, their predecessors, Indian Head pennies, often develop some of the most spectacular blue toning patterns of any American coins.

“The slightly different copper alloy employed for Indian cents seems particularly well-suited to blues and purples,” said long-time dealer Frank Wilson. “When these older coins were stored in velvet-lined cabinets or some of those cardboard folder varieties, great color patterns would develop over the course of decades.”

These “album-toned” Indian cents, particularly those bearing dates in the 19th century, are quite coveted by collectors who prefer them toned. The contrast of copper-red fields against blue-to-purple devices makes these coins extremely pleasing to the eyes and superior to normal numismatic considerations.

Wilson showed an 1899 Indian cent with deep blue toning that was concentrated in the portrait and date areas. “Twenty years ago, this would have fetched $30. Now, the right collector would gladly pay $400 for this quality of art.”

10. Modern Plating Errors: Blue Zinc Exposures

Value Range: $5–$100

With the majority of U.S. cents since 1982 struck on zinc planchets with a thin layer of copper plating, when such plating is absent or worn away, the underlying zinc core of the coin becomes visible and when this oxidizes, it often creates those bluish-white designs.

“Such plating failures are quite common,” said error expert Sophia James. “But examples with attractive designs or heavy blue toning have developed their own cult.” Most valuable specimens create stunning, even exposures, causing two-tone effects on the portrait of Lincoln.

Read More:- $270,000 Lincoln Penny Still in Circulation – Are You One of the Lucky Ones?

Particularly attractive specimens, in which the blue-white zinc exposure creates aesthetic contrast with the copper, are sold for $50-100 to professionals. I seek out ones where Lincoln’s face is copper but his hair or the background behind him is that blue zinc,” said James. “When the mistake results in a nice visual effect, it becomes something artistic rather than a flaw.”

Hunting for Blue Treasures: Top 10 Blue Penny Coins by Value

After spending time with these collectors and seeing their blue-penny treasures, I’ve developed a new appreciation for the coins jangling in my pocket. While discovering a six-figure rarity is still unlikely, the chance that a fascinating blue-colored coin could be lurking in plain sight makes something as dull as draining my change jar exciting.

As Martin Weiss warned when I first met him, “Check your steel cents for perfect blue toning. Look at memorial cents for natural blue patinas in the areas around the building. And don’t clean anything that pretty blue is sometimes worth more than one hundred times the coin’s value.”

Whether driven by history, scientific curiosity, or just their odd allure, blue pennies are a fascinating niche in American numismatics one perhaps available to anyone with spare change and an observant eye.

FAQs:-